The Necessity of Imagination

Learning To See What Isn’t There Yet

Everything we deliberately create begins, in some sense, before it exists. Before we build something, we have some idea of what we’re trying to build. Before we change direction, we consider another direction. Before we prepare for a difficult conversation, we imagine how that conversation might go. Before we become capable of doing something we’ve never done before, we have to entertain the possibility that we could become capable of doing it. That capacity is imagination.

We often associate imagination with childhood, creativity, fantasy, fiction, or escaping from ordinary reality. Those are certainly ways imagination can be used. But imagination also performs a much more fundamental function. It allows us to internally interact with possibilities that aren’t immediately present in front of us. And if we’re talking about personal development—about deliberately participating in who we become—that ability is not optional. We have to be able to see something that isn’t there yet.

Imagination Isn’t The Opposite Of Reason

There is sometimes an unnecessary division between imagination and rational thought. One is treated as fanciful. The other is treated as serious. But imagination and reason can perform different parts of the same process. Imagination can ask: What if? Reason can ask: Does that make sense? Observation can ask: What is actually happening? Experiment can ask: What happens if we try it? Then the results give imagination something new to work with.

This process appears everywhere. An inventor imagines something that doesn’t exist. A scientist considers a possible explanation that hasn’t been demonstrated. An entrepreneur imagines a business that hasn’t been built. An athlete mentally rehearses performance. An artist creates something that previously existed only as an idea.

And when we deliberately work on ourselves, we do something similar. Who might I become that I am not yet? Imagination allows us to entertain the possibility. It doesn’t establish that the possibility is true. That’s an important distinction.

Possibility Is Not Reality

Imagination can produce extraordinary things. It can also produce complete nonsense. Fear uses imagination. So does catastrophizing. Wishful thinking uses imagination. So does suspicion. We can imagine what someone else is thinking and become angry with them over something they never thought. We can imagine a future and become emotionally attached to an event that hasn’t happened. We can imagine failure so convincingly that we never attempt something. We can imagine success so vividly that we mistake imagining the accomplishment for actually accomplishing it.

So imagination needs other faculties around it. Imagination generates possibilities. Observation gives us information. Reason examines relationships. Experience provides feedback. Discernment helps us differentiate. And eventually we choose what to do.

The problem isn’t imagining something that isn’t real. That’s part of the function. The problem begins when we forget the distinction between: “I can imagine this.” And “Therefore, this is true.” A disciplined imagination can remain extraordinarily open without requiring us to believe everything it produces.

Imagination Allows Us To Change Perspective

Perspective-taking itself requires imagination. We only directly experience the world from where we are. But we can ask: What might this look like from where someone else is standing? We don’t magically enter their mind. We construct a possible perspective. Then we examine it. What might they know that we don’t? What might we know that they don’t? What experiences might cause them to interpret the same situation differently?

We can do the same thing with time. What will this problem look like tomorrow? A year from now? Ten years from now? What would my younger self think about where I am today? What might the person I’m trying to become think about the decision I’m making now?

None of these imagined perspectives are automatically correct. But they allow us to temporarily move beyond the perspective we’re currently occupying. That creates possibilities we couldn’t see from only one position.

We Can Rehearse Before We Act

Human beings do this constantly. We rehearse conversations in our heads. Imagine possible outcomes. Consider what we might say. Anticipate someone’s response. Sometimes we do it deliberately. Sometimes our minds do it without being asked.

The ability itself can be trained and used more consciously. Suppose we know we need to establish a difficult boundary. We can imagine the conversation. What do we actually need to communicate? How might the other person respond? What happens if they become angry? What if they agree? What if they attempt to redirect the conversation? What emotional responses arise in us while we’re imagining those possibilities?

Now we’re not simply fantasizing. We’re preparing. Then reality gets the final vote. We have the conversation. We observe what actually happens. Maybe our preparation was useful. Maybe the person responds in a way we never considered. That gives us new information. And our internal model changes.

Internal Work Requires An Internal Space

Imagination becomes even more important when development moves inward. How do we examine something that isn’t physically sitting in front of us? Memories. Possible futures. Alternative perspectives. Symbols. Parts of our personality. Emotional experiences. Values. Our conception of ourselves. The person we’re trying to become. We need some form of internal representation. Different people may experience this differently. Some people have vivid visual imagery. Others think more through language, concepts, sensations, spatial relationships, or combinations of them. The particular form matters less than the capacity itself. We need somewhere internally to work with things that aren’t immediately physically present.

This is one reason imagery and symbolism appear so frequently in spiritual, contemplative, religious, and esoteric traditions. Symbols allow complicated relationships to be represented in condensed forms. Visualization allows us to deliberately interact with internal imagery. Stories allow us to explore human problems outside the immediate circumstances of our own lives. Ritual can give internal concepts external actions and forms. And that last point matters considerably. Because imagination doesn’t have to remain internal.

Imagination Can Become Embodied

This is where imagination becomes especially important to personal development. It isn’t enough merely to imagine the person we want to become. Eventually that person has to do something. We hear versions of this everywhere. Follow your dreams. Make your dreams reality. Create the life you want. Bring heaven to earth. Become the person you imagine yourself capable of becoming.

Different traditions and philosophies use different language, but there is a common movement hidden inside many of these ideas: Something begins internally and eventually has to encounter the physical world. We imagine. Then we return. We envision a possibility and ask: What would this actually look like if I lived it?

Suppose I imagine myself becoming more disciplined. That’s an idea. What does discipline look like tomorrow morning? Suppose I want to become compassionate. Wonderful. How do I behave when compassion becomes inconvenient? Suppose I imagine a healthier body. What am I going to eat? How am I going to move? What habits need to change? Suppose a spiritual practice gives me an extraordinary perspective on love, interconnectedness, courage, or responsibility. What happens when I come back from that experience? How do I speak? How do I behave? How do I treat another person? The body is where imagination begins encountering action.

Hands build what the mind conceived. Feet carry us toward somewhere we decided to go. The voice says what we previously rehearsed internally. Repeated behavior gradually develops capacities that once existed only as possibilities. This is one reason I keep returning to the present.

Go There – Then Come Back

Imagination allows us to travel surprisingly far without physically moving anywhere. Into the past. Into possible futures. Into another perspective. Into symbolic worlds. Into spiritual imagery. Into an ideal. Into the darkest possibility we fear or the highest possibility we can conceive. There can be tremendous value in going there. But personal development doesn’t end there. We come back.

This follows the same movement I’ve described elsewhere through descent and ascent. Sometimes we go downward into depth because something needs to be understood. Then we return to the present. Sometimes we move upward into broader perspective because we need to see beyond our current position. Then we return to the present.

Imagination participates in both movements. It allows us to enter places internally that aren’t identical to our immediate physical circumstances. But the present is where we integrate whatever we found. Otherwise imagination can become another form of escape. We can spend years imagining who we’re going to become without practicing becoming that person. We can accumulate beautiful spiritual ideas without embodying any of them. We can visualize an extraordinary future while neglecting the ordinary actions required to create it. At some point: The imagined possibility has to meet the person standing here.

Imagination Gives Development A Direction

If we cannot imagine ourselves behaving differently, changing deliberately becomes much harder. Suppose we’re working on anger. We know how we currently respond. Can we imagine another response? What would it look like? What skills would that version of us need? More emotional regulation? Better communication? Greater tolerance for discomfort? Stronger boundaries? More patience? Now imagination has exposed a gap between who we currently are and who we could potentially become.

That gap gives us something to work on. We imagine. Then practice. Observe. Adjust. Practice again. Eventually something that originally existed only as a possibility becomes something we’re actually capable of doing. That’s embodiment. And once embodied, it isn’t merely an idea anymore.

Imagination Needs Contact With Reality

This is why I don’t think developing imagination means abandoning reality. I think the opposite relationship is more useful. Imagination expands possibility. Reality provides resistance and feedback. We need both. Imagination without reality can become fantasy. Reality without imagination can convince us that what currently exists is all that ever could. One gives us possibility. The other gives us consequence.

Together they allow experimentation. We imagine another way. Try it. See what happens. Learn. Imagine again. That’s not very different from the process involved in self-education, physical training, emotional development, creative work, or learning almost any new skill.

Learning To Use What We Already Have

Most of us don’t need to acquire imagination from nothing. We’re already using it. The more useful questions may be: How am I using mine? Do I mostly imagine what could go wrong? Do I imagine possibilities I never attempt? Can I genuinely imagine another person’s perspective? Can I mentally rehearse something difficult without convincing myself the rehearsal predicts exactly what will happen? Can I use symbols or imagery to examine something I struggle to express directly? Can I imagine myself possessing qualities I haven’t fully developed yet? And if I can: What would I actually have to do to develop them?

That’s where imagination becomes developmental rather than merely entertaining. It gives us somewhere to explore before we act. Somewhere to rehearse. Somewhere to construct. Somewhere to temporarily stand when our current perspective isn’t enough. And somewhere to see possibilities that aren’t visible yet.

But eventually we have to leave that internal space. We have to return to the body. To behavior. To relationships. To consequences. To the present. To life. Imagination allows us to temporarily enter somewhere we haven’t reached yet. Development is the process of building a road from here to there. And embodiment is where we begin walking it.

The Highs and Lows of Life.

While psychology and esoteric systems can sometimes diverge depending on your perspective, there are two areas in which both sides often seem to encounter similar developmental territory: descent and ascension.

Below The Surface

Many older traditions, particularly those concerned with depth, shadow, initiation, and transformation, contain journeys into darkness, underworlds, death and rebirth, ordeals, confrontations with monsters, periods of isolation, and symbolic dismemberment followed by reconstruction. Psychology has its own languages for confronting painful, avoided, unconscious, contradictory, or previously unintegrated material. We descend. Into history. Into emotion. Into patterns. Into fear. Into the unconscious. Into whatever darkness lies beneath the person we presently experience ourselves to be.

The explanations aren’t identical.  But the developmental principle is recognizable: Sometimes you cannot understand what is happening on the surface without exploring what lies underneath it. A reaction may have a history. A belief may have been formed under circumstances you’ve forgotten. A strength may have grown from something painful. A behavior that causes problems today may once have solved a problem extremely well. So, we descend. This is not necessarily movement backward in the developmental sense. It is movement toward depth. You follow the present downward into what helped create it. And there are things worth finding there. But finding them isn’t enough. You must carry them back.

The objective isn’t to construct a permanent home at the bottom of the spiral. The objective is to return to where you began with something you didn’t possess when you left. Understanding. Awareness. Acceptance. A different interpretation. A lesson. A choice. A recovered part of yourself. Whatever was found at depth must encounter the present person before it can become part of present life.

The Other Side of Experience

A great deal of spiritual language also points upward. Higher consciousness. Higher Self. Ascension. Transcendence. Enlightenment. Liberation. The imagery is understandable. Height gives us perspective. Rising above something allows us to see relationships that may be invisible while standing inside them. Many spiritual traditions therefore associate development with ascent—with reaching beyond the limitations of our ordinary perspective toward something greater.

As we move upward conceptually, perspective expands. From close enough, an event can occupy your entire field of vision. Move farther away and it becomes one event among many. Move farther still and relationships between events become visible. Patterns appear. What seemed random may acquire context. What seemed overwhelmingly important may become smaller. What seemed insignificant may reveal itself as part of something much larger. This is one reason spiritual and contemplative traditions have always been attracted to the symbolism of ascent. Higher perspective can change understanding.

But there is a danger here too. Perspective can become distance. If the objective becomes permanently escaping the ordinary human condition—escaping the body, emotion, difficulty, responsibility, relationship, limitation, or material life—then the very perspective that was supposed to expand life can become a means of withdrawing from it. I don’t regard transcendence as useless. I question transcendence that never returns. If you climb high enough to see something that couldn’t be seen from the ground, then bring what you saw back to the ground. That is where it becomes practical.

A spiritual realization should eventually encounter behavior. A philosophical understanding should eventually encounter decisions. Greater consciousness should eventually encounter ordinary relationships. Expanded perspective should eventually encounter responsibility. Whatever happens in meditation eventually encounters the person who gets up from meditation. Whatever happens during ritual eventually encounters the person who leaves the ritual space. Whatever is learned in solitude eventually encounters another human being. Whatever is discovered beyond the ordinary perspective eventually has to be expressed through an ordinary life if it is going to become part of that life.

The Present Is the Point of Contact

It could be easy to misunderstand this and think the present is simply a neutral midpoint between darkness below and light above. For me, this is where spirituality and personal development become inseparable. Below you is depth. Above you is perspective. You can travel downward to understand what lies beneath your present condition. You can travel upward to see your present condition from increasingly larger perspectives.

But the life you are actually living is occurring here. In the present. That makes the present something more than the starting point of the journey. It is the place where what you discover elsewhere becomes capable of affecting your life. You can descend into the past and discover why a particular pattern exists. Useful. But eventually you must return to the present and ask:

What am I going to do differently now that I understand it? You can ascend into an extraordinary spiritual perspective and experience yourself, humanity, consciousness, or existence in a completely different way. Useful. But eventually you must return and ask: How does someone who has seen that live differently tomorrow morning? Without that return, insight can remain insight. Integration requires embodiment. That makes the present the grounds of integration. It is where the different directions meet. It is where information becomes choice. It is where perspective becomes action. It is where understanding becomes behavior. It is where the past encounters the possibility of a different future. It is where the spiritual encounters the physical. It is where whatever you believe about consciousness, soul, meaning, or existence must encounter the fact that right now you are also a human being living a human life.

You descend. You return. You ascend. You return. And each return potentially changes the person standing there. You can encounter similar territory repeatedly while experiencing it from a different depth or height. You may return to an old question years later and discover that it is no longer asking quite the same thing, because you are no longer the same person asking the question. Extraordinary experiences can be valuable. So can profound psychological insights. So can symbolic experiences, difficult confrontations with yourself, periods of contemplation, and moments when your perspective seems to expand beyond anything you previously understood. Because I believe greater depth and greater perspective can help us become increasingly capable of engaging with life and being human deliberately.